A SUPERSTITION OF THE POOR
The following story is the recreation of a story written many years ago by the Young J. Its original title was "Notes From A Diary." A major motion picture with different characters, and an entirely different spirit, but with certain vague conceptual parallels, appeared after the writing of this story, and dissuaded the author from pursuing his idea any further. However, the impact of that movie has faded with time, and there is no longer any reason to obscure a very different sensibility and take on its account. That is, to say, the condition of eclipse has ended; history has returned the original artistic space to the author.
March 23
: Rio de Janeiro is quite a city. What a different feel! We arrived via VARIG last night, after miles of darkness flying over a country which didn’t seem to exist. "Are you sure this isn’t the sea?" I asked Dirse, who was born 24 years ago in this land, never knowing it was her destiny to meet me."No, this is Brasil," she told me. "Right now, we’re probably over Goias or Minas Gerais."
"It looks like there’s nobody down there," I said.
She said: "That’s how it’s always looked to you."
I asked her if she was talking about me or my country. She just looked away and stared out the window at, what for me, was emptiness. I do love her passion, which sometimes inhabits silence. And I more than tolerate her views, I positively rejoice in them no matter how inconvenient they are to me. Her political incorrectness is simply charming; paradise itself would be a bore if there wasn’t someone to pluck feathers out of the angels’ wings. As long as they can still fly, what’s the difference?
Finally, after an hour that seemed to be a container for infinity, we saw the tiny candles of towns appearing in the night, leading us, like footprints, towards significant concentrations of human habitation. And then, the great bowl of lights that was Rio de Janeiro appeared beneath the red wing lights of our airplane, crying out to the universe that there was life here, after all. It seemed to me that we were about to crash into a field when suddenly a runway appeared below and we were back on the earth, glad to end our momentary, awkward imitation of the birds. Dirse and I hugged, and she said: "Welcome to my country."
Since then, we have spent two days in the hotel waiting to be transferred to the secure compound, although the hotel itself is quite safe, patrolled by soldiers with automatic rifles who smile little, and would frisk their own mother, which is most reassuring to us. Though Dirse warned me against it, I went out onto the street for a little breath of fresh air and saw the dark faces we have come to help: pure black faces, straight from Africa, boisterous, curious, and sometimes hostile; Indian faces with that impassive beauty cracked open like a vault by the extroversion which surrounds them; white faces that could be European, like foam on the surface of an ocean of color; and everywhere, a most incredible mixture of the races: mulattos, mulattas, mestizos, mestizas, zambos, zambas, hybrids of both extraordinary beauty and ugliness, Galateas and Calibans, genetic masterpieces and genetic disasters, surly chimeras and brilliant pioneers of the cosmic race. It is like a rainbow blowing up in your face. For the last two nights, I have not been able to shut them out of my mind, even with my eyes closed and covered with an opaque cloth in my bedroom; they have swarmed into my consciousness like the army ants which eat huge paths through the jungle, devouring flowers the size of plates. "Where are you from?" they asked me.
I’ve been told to say I am from Ireland, but I told them: "From the U.S."
Some of them stretched out their hands to me and said, "Well, good luck. If you manage to put up with us, we’ll find a way to put up with you."
Those who didn’t like me merely shrugged and said, "It can’t be helped."
When I told Dirse about my walk, she slapped me saying I had risked my life. She made me promise never to go out on my own again.
March 28
: Two nights ago we finally got an apartment in the secure compound. It has polished wooden floors, ceiling fans, wicker chairs, a sofa and a painting of a protective, fatherly soldier holding a little girl in his arms. Judging from its quality, it could have been painted by an elementary school student. But if that’s so, the bed in our room must have been made by a fetus. Any time you move at all it protests with a loud squeak and bounces for what seems like a minute before becoming stationary again; there is barely room for one person to sleep in it, let alone two. Perhaps if what they say about Latin lovers is true, the bed wasn’t made for sleeping. As long as one of the partners is on top of the other there seems to be room for both. There is also a piece of metal spring protruding from the mattress like a fishhook, I found out last night what it is like to be a trout. As for the stove, Dirse is afraid to use it because the gas comes out with so much force that she imagines one day it will blow up like a bomb. Well, who says food has to be cooked? Anyhow, this is the secure zone. Tomorrow I meet with the Civic Action program.March 29
: A most amazing meeting today! Dr. Robert Chafing and Colonel Bradley Barry, along with Captain Joao Mendez of the ASB (the Brazilian Security Apparatus) and Dr. Elias Bari of the "Doctors of Content", briefed us on our mission. With me were ten other members of the Hand-to the-World program, as well as our coordinator from the State Department, Mr. Jack Rabey. We are all to work in Bairro Capanga, a favela, or slum, beyond the inner wall but still within the broad perimeter. Our purpose is to provide quality medical care to impoverished city residents who are essentially disconnected from the healthcare system, and to improve the image of our country in an SRA (susceptible-to-revolutionary-activity) zone by means of our active and beneficial presence in the community. We have been told that there is a resurgence of malaria and dengue, as well as chronic dysentery, Type 3 resistant TB, occasional outbreaks of typhoid and cholera, all sorts of parasitic infections, venereal diseases galore and AIDS (up to 40% of the population) as well as skin-disfigurement virus (SDV) which seems to have been released from deforestation in Acre into the general Brazilian environment, and specifically brought back here by the sons of several old-time residents. We’ll be accompanied by a light platoon of the ASB and quartered in an old stone house that was abandoned by its owners years ago when the area became infested with bandits.According to Colonel Barry, we have arrived at a moment of intense excitement, as a new folktale has just begun circulating throughout the city, probably originating from Pernambuco or Recife in the Northeast. There’s always something going on that way. According to the legend, after Cuba was liberated from the Communists after the death of Fidel Castro, the CIA found records of an extraordinary effort to produce a clone of Ernesto "Che" Guevara, the Argentine doctor turned revolutionary who was the military genius and principal ideological architect of the Cuban Revolution. Apparently, semen samples were collected before his ill-fated expedition to Bolivia and preserved, possibly to facilitate the artificial insemination of his wife should he die in battle, so that she could have another child by him after his death should she wish to. Somehow, the samples were sent on to Sweden, sometime around 2000, where they came into the possession of a Dr. Gustav Johansson, Europe’s foremost expert in cloning. Dr. Johansson insists that the samples were misplaced and lost sometime around 2008, but according to the latest urban legend, which is spreading through Brazil like wildfire, a clone of Che Guevara was produced sometime early in the new millennium; and that clone is now being trained and prepared to renew the revolutionary struggle which was interrupted by his death, and to lead Latin America and all the nations of the Periphery in an apocalyptic upheaval against the US and the United World Center. Some even say that Che is already here, in Brazil, the most logical flashpoint for the great conflagration, his glaring eyes looking out upon the enemy, which is us, his wild hair blowing in the wind, like a prophet who walks on bullets, a gun in his hand, no match on the battlefield for our armored cars, our helicopters and our predators, yet more powerful than all of them combined, because it is like the staff of Moses, that can part the seas
.According to Colonel Barry, there is nothing to this legend, but it has nonetheless, become a force to be reckoned with because people believe in it, and it gives them hope. The ERB, the rebel army which was in tatters only six months ago, is said to be regrouping, and its urban cells revitalizing, on the basis of this legend, which is inspiring beaten men to try again. More than this, Colonel Barry fears the impact of this new myth on the gigantic masses of the discontented and the volatile," the shapeless, latent force of the poor", whose apathy, if ignited, could be as devastating as an avalanche; and if, injected with leadership, as lethal as a car bomb.
Whereas Mr. Rabey prefers to see the legend as a sign of collapse in the revolutionary movement, because, as he says: "When tangible and plausible forms of resistance become impossible, men resort to mystical solutions, to delusions of divine intervention
, to superstitions of salvation, to millenarian pipedreams which actually represent a withdrawal from active participation in changing their fate. This happened in the case of the Taki Onqoy movement in colonial Peru and in the case of the Ghost Dance movement at the end of the Indian wars in the United States. Instead of shooting, the Indians danced in circles, fainting and hallucinating, and prayed for a giant dust storm to bury the white race. We all know how that turned out." Rabey noted the tendency of the "imaginative and superstition-ridden" Brazilian mind to concoct all sorts of alternative realities which waylay them from the real world (which is good for us), citing the case of other urban myths, like the legend of Silvio the crack-dealer, who could breathe underwater like a fish and make himself invisible to the police; or Ana Alves, "the violated", who wandered around the slums every night getting raped to protect other women, because once a man’s penis went into her vagina, he could never use it again and was impotent for life; or the true-life story of the crazy homeless people who found a discarded piece of medical equipment with radioactive cesium in it in a garbage dump, and because the cesium gave off an eerie green glow in the night, they thought it was a magical and divine substance, and rubbed it all over their bodies and even ate it, until they became sick and died. For Rabey, the Che legend is more of the same, a wonderful case of "the modern production of mythology" which should be of great interest to urban anthropologists. He dismisses the threat, stating that Che Guevara, in real life, was a flawed revolutionary who got lucky in Cuba but reaped the just deserts of his strategic unsoundness in Bolivia. "Lenin and Mao were formidable revolutionaries," Rabey said; "Guevara was nothing but a rock star with an assault rifle. He makes a great poster and T-shirt." According to Rabey, after his death, once he could "no longer shit in the pants of the ideal people had of him", Che was practically deified, "the fate of many fools", and now in Bolivia, the land that killed him, peasants even light candles for him and make him offerings of cigarettes in order that he grant them a wish. "He has become a minor god, like Pan, who he resembled in life." Rabey believes that the Che myth will make waves for a little while, then once he does not appear, or an impostor surfaces to discredit the new religion, this millenarian movement, as all others before it, will evaporate: "Like the people who wait for the earth to be destroyed by a comet on a specific day at a specific hour; after the hour passes, they feel pretty silly and just go home."Colonel Barry disagreed with Rabey’s dismissal, insisting that from the military point of view, psychology cannot be completely pushed aside by material factors. "Myths can be as dangerous as trenches and foxholes, they can give shelter to the enemy. Real people can shoot you from inside a myth. We are experiencing a period of heightened agitation on the basis of this runaway urban legend. In this context, the importance of the Hand-to-the-World program as an image-changer for our nation, and a rage-squelcher here in Brazil cannot be overemphasized. We need to counteract the escalation of revolutionary energy with a perceptual reconstruction of the meaning of our presence, and the motives of the ASB."
By the time the meeting was over I felt more like a sociologist than a doctor; more like a part of the military-police apparatus than a disciple of Aesculapius.
When I told Dirse about the meeting she just told me, "Your Mr. Rabies knows next to nothing. That Che Guevara was a hell of a fighter. The very thought of him coming here to fight would be enough to make me throw in my lot with the guerrillas. With those eyes like a French kiss…"
I told her, "You shouldn’t make jokes like that, not at a time like this." Sometimes it isn’t easy to live with such a livewire. Sometimes, the hot pepper is just a little too hot.
April 5
: It was hard to say good-bye to Dirse, especially given the intense nature of my assignment. She’ll stay here in Brazil in the secure compound so that we’ll be able to see each other on my days off. I told her, "Hold the fort down while I’m gone." She cried, and I told her, "The bed’s only big enough for one, anyway." She punched me. God, how I love people who aren’t normal! I should have gone into psychiatry rather than foreign medicine.Captain Mendez escorted us out of the secure zone in a lorry preceded by a jeep with a machine gun mounted on it and followed by an armored car with a machine gun that merits the name of "cannon", and tubes that looked like organ pipes in a church for launching rockets. When I asked him for a pistol for myself, to put in my belt, since our armed escort only succeeded in making the situation seem more alarming than it already was – to us it seemed like we were divers being given an empty can of shark repellent, which simultaneously lets you know that there are sharks in the water and that you have no defense against them - Captain Mendez protested, "Don’t you trust us to protect you?"
I answered, "Well, just in case a soccer match comes on." Three weeks before, in Sao Paulo, there was a major prison break while guards were gathered around TVs watching Brazil play Argentina, so Captain Mendez knew what I was talking about. He had no choice but to laugh.
"Here," he said, giving me his own pistol. ".38 caliber, clip holds eight bullets, here’s two spares. Here’s the safety. Don’t shoot one of your patients, god damn it. Do you know how to fire this thing?"
"Of course," I told him, "I come from the land of the cowboys."
"John Wayne’s been dead a long time," he said.
"Don’t worry. I’m good with gadgets, machines, all this kind of stuff. I’m a typical Yankee. Benjamin Franklin, Eli Whitney, Robert Fulton, Thomas Edison, the Wright Brothers, Henry Ford, Bill Gates and now there’s me. Here’s the trigger. ("Careful!" he told me.) I can turn on a light switch and I can flush a toilet. How hard can it be?"
The captain patted me on the back and on we went. Past the trench and barbed wire and sandbags of the compound, down the walled through-road with its sniper’s towers and observation balloons, and out of the inner wall, with its trenches, strategic pillboxes, and minefields. As we moved out towards Bairro Capanga, we had to stop and wait for a moment, a funeral was passing by, a huge crowd of mourners carrying a tiny wooden box on their shoulders.
"What’s going on there?" I asked the captain. One of his soldiers came back from talking with the mourners and told us, "Funeral. Yesterday, a kid ran onto the minefield to try to help a stray dog who she had begun to feed, so that even though it was wild it sort of became her pet. Anyway, the dog tripped a mine and got blown up but it was wailing so pitifully she ran out after it to try to carry it back and she ended up stepping on a mine too. It blew her leg off and made a huge hole in her stomach, they say her guts were dangling out like pig intestines which you hang up to dry. They say there’s no doctor around here for miles, and they couldn’t get past the checkpoint to get to the hospital."
"From the description," I told them, "it sounds like the wound was fatal. Barring a top-notch field hospital and helicopter evacuation services, no one could have saved her."
"Imagine," the captain said: "Feeding a pet dog, even though they don’t have enough to eat themselves. But they breed like roaches, and for them, condoms are a sin. Negroes are too hot-blooded to think when they get the urge, they just jump into bed and pop!, out comes another one! One more mouth to feed. We really made a mistake not to go ahead with the forced sterilization program, but they measure their worth by the size of their dicks and the number of starving brats they put into the world, so who’s going to rope them like cows just so you can pull out the plumbing?"
I found the captain’s comments disturbing, but since our lives depend on him and his men, it would be well not to be repelled. Aversion is one of the easiest emotions to detect.
After a while, the parade of tragedy passed, headed off to some pitiful spot of dust to bury a girl who loved a dog. The world will go on without her. Flowers will bloom without her; the moon will still come into the sky even though she’s not here to look at it. It makes you wonder, when you look at the stars at night, who’s not looking at them, and why?
With the road clear ahead of us, we kept on driving towards the neighborhood we have been assigned to save. Above us, like a guardian angel, a robot plane, the Predator
, appeared, its frightening form leaving no doubt as to its capabilities. Some shapes you know are lethal, just by seeing them – there is something about the body of the black widow spider, something about the menacing triangular head of the pit-viper, something about the perfect knife-like body of the shark, gliding through the water without shame or fear. And it’s the same with the Predator, with its teeth of machine guns and its claws of missiles. Somewhere far away, behind its camera eyes, a pair of human eyes was glued to a video screen watching the misery around us, searching for the slightest trace of opposition. It’s strange, sometimes, how morally terrifying safety can be.It was nearing dusk when we finally drove up a dirt road into a hellhole that looked more like an encampment than a neighborhood. There was a little wooden sign on a tree that had forgotten to die which said "Bairro Capanga." It looked like a hurricane had struck, or like some great ship in the sky had exploded and rained its debris all over the earth in the form of the dwellings in which these people lived: shacks made of cardboard, wood, and tin; tarps turned into roofs and strung across trenches and ravines; little caverns dug into the sides of hills, with furniture made of boxes, and crosses hanging on the walls; external cooking - ovens of stones with tiny fires glowing inside them, leaking smoke into the air, or makeshift stoves fueled by tanks of propane gas; outdoor toilets which were wooden boxes with holes in them built over pits; outdoor showers, made out of water cans with holes punched into the bottom, surrounded by clotheslines covered with rags; a well for drinking water down the road; pools of stagnant water and open sewage to the side, and the huge garbage dump which they called "Pearls to Swine" looming behind them in the distance, like an enchanted tower, like the home of a mad alchemist who could transmute one world’s puke into another world’s gold; a ziggurat of waste where men and vultures fought like gladiators for life, where desperation gave pathetic pieces of junk the value of diamonds. All around us, as we entered the slum, lay emaciated dogs, saving their energy for an emergency, it seemed. An angry woman yelled at us for nearly running over her chickens, though, in fact, they never even came close to the road, as a stray goat, dragging a tether attached to nothing, stood puzzled by a spiny plant on a hillside, which had drawn its sword.
I had been forewarned, but this first impression of Bairro Capanga was more than the imagination could steel one for
.As we drove up along the dirt road, absolutely intimidated by the people we had come to save, they gathered around to watch us pass. My colleague, Dr. Vega, who had features not far removed from the roots of these people, made a brave show of it, and waved to the sullen, skeptical witnesses who watched us arrive, forcing something approximating a smile onto his face. But there was no response; absolutely no response, it was as if we had driven into a land of statues. To me, the eyes of our new patients reminded me of the telescopic lenses of snipers’ rifles. There was nothing in their hearts; in the midst of the tropics we had entered a world of ice.
For a moment, our convoy struggled to get a grip on the dirt road that seemed to want to disappear back into the mountain; it was like a mistake on a piece of paper that wanted to be erased. A feeling of dread overcame us, the thought of stalling out here, of our vehicles failing us, of displaying our helplessness before such freezing eyes was enough to induce panic. For a moment, we felt like prisoners being led to the gallows. One doctor even urinated in his pants. But then, thank God, the engines triumphed, the wheels dug like picks into the trail that would not help, and finally, we bounded over the crest of a hill, and coasted down the other side to the great stone house we had been assigned to occupy. To us, it looked as reassuring as a castle with a drawbridge.
April 7
: Two days here, and not a good beginning. When we rumbled up into the circular driveway outside the great stone house, we were met by a detachment of the army, whose vehicles were parked inside a barbed wire enclosure in the back. A violent dog by the name of "Teeth" greeted us by lunging against his handler’s leash, like a madman trying to burst free of a straitjacket. Apparently after the great stone house was abandoned by its owners years before, it came to be inhabited by a number of families from the neighborhood, and in its heyday may have accommodated up to fifty people. During "wash-outs" – the driving rainstorms which wreak havoc on the most flimsy of shelters in the bairro - many more people from the neighborhood would crowd inside, welcomed by the stone house families who didn’t know how to say no. Captain Mendez says that these people love to be generous with things that don’t belong to them. Anyway, at those times, according to what we hear, the place was so crowded that you couldn’t even walk without stepping on someone. Once the plan to move our civic action team into the stone house was formed, it became necessary to send in a unit of the police, a property-protection squad, to recover the residence from the squatters. When they refused to leave, the army sent in back-up, and, in fact, several canisters of teargas had to be fired through the windows before the residents could be convinced to leave. An old man named Don Cristovao died in the turmoil from a heart attack. Once the house had been "cleaned up", the army left a detachment behind to prevent reoccupation until our arrival. Now that we are here with Colonel Mendez’s platoon, they have told us that they are packing up and moving on to a trouble spot near Vassouras tomorrow, and that from now on, our security will be in the hands of Colonel Mendez. We feel like shipwrecked sailors in a lifeboat, alone on a vast, unfriendly ocean wracked by storms.Yesterday, we convoked a neighborhood meeting at a place called "The Fountain", where the neighborhood well is located and where the people often spend hours hanging out and exchanging news. "It is their own version of the Roman Forum," Mendez explained to us. "Or Behind The Scenes [which is a popular magazine that specializes in gossip]. Poor people love to talk about who’s sleeping with who; the women compare the size of their lovers’ penises, and the men ask around to see who’s giving it out." When we showed up, Dr. Bari explained to the people why we were here and what we proposed to do for them, but he seemed like one of those mentally ill people who you sometimes see on the trains, talking to himself, or to some imaginary angel or demon. The people just went about their business, taking water out of the well, watching us from a distance with their arms crossed, then turning away from us and resuming their conversations in quieter tones, until finally they lost all respect for us, and began laughing with each other again and drowning out our offers of help with all the latest news from the bairro. They couldn’t read the leaflets that we handed out to them.
One man said, "You’ve come too late to save Don Cristovao. But if you want to, you can dig him up, and try to bring him back to life."
While a woman told me, "My arm’s already covered with mosquito bites, do you think I want the bite of your needle on top of it? But if you really want to help me, carry this jug of water back to my house." I did it, while some of the other women laughed and said, "That’s a nice puppy dog." It seems that sometimes the willingness to help is interpreted as stupidity, or softness, which is even worse. One of Mendez’s soldiers accompanied me just to make sure nothing happened. "I do this every day," the woman told me, when I gave her back the water when we reached her house, which was a dilapidated shack - and that is all she said.
After this first encounter with the residents of the neighborhood, Dr. Bari said, "We need to give them some time to get used to us."
April 15
: The stay in Bairro Capanga remains harrowing. The resentment against the government, against the US which supports that government, and against the nations of the United Center which jointly maintain the Periphery, is strong. The people understand politics only vaguely, but they live by the distorted perspective which reaches them through their suffering, like the light of the sun filtered into the depths of the ocean. They receive the truth of the world through their pain. Whoever is not poor must be blamed. Besides this, the stone house which we now occupy was theirs till only a couple months ago, and the wound of losing it is still open. They find it amazingly ironical that we have come to help them, and that the first act of our mission of mercy has been to take over their stone house and render fifty of them homeless. Word is that the neighborhood is filled with jokes about us. They wrestle with every outrage of the universe with muscular arms of black humor, inherited from the first taste of chains that brought their ancestors here; they turn the most devastating nightmares into jokes and find a way to laugh, which is like finding water in the desert; they bound away from unlivable despair like antelopes from lions, with the fleet feet of their sense of humor, which does not dispel their anger, only save them from their lack of power. We have come with vaccines and medicines, but they already have the medicine of cynicism. According to our informants, people are going around in the bairro now, punching each other, stepping on each other’s feet, and even spitting at each other, saying, "Hi, I’m Dr. Bari. I’ve come to save you." No one seems to be offended, they are having a great time with this new comedy they have invented.Since no one is coming to us, and Dr. Bari has rejected Captain Mendez’s suggestion to round up the townsfolk and force them to be vaccinated, "because our mission is just as much political as it is medical", we have begun to do things on our own. We have begun to dig drainage channels to clear away some of the stagnant water which is breeding mosquitoes, and we’ve asked for help from the Sanitation Agency in constructing a modern sewage system here; but the paperwork still has to be filed, and after that, it could still take up to ten years to get any results. We’ve also been wandering around the bairro, always accompanied by military support, looking at the people and attempting to make visual diagnoses even though they won’t submit to examinations. We already think we’ve discovered two cases of TB and possibly three of SDV. But Dr. Bari is considering suspending these forays, due to the superstition of the people, who may believe we are trying to perform some sort of magic against them by staring into their eyes and robbing them of their souls, or else trying to hypnotize them as part of some covert government operation to gain control of their minds. "We have entered a completely alien mentality here," Dr. Bari told us; "a world of magical realism, where fantasies reign supreme. Since they have not had access to modern medicine for years, they have developed other ways of coping with disease. They pray to spirits; they go to healers who sprinkle water from the sea over them; they burn images of sickness
, which they have made out of newspapers, in fire. They don’t believe they need us and, in fact, by coming to us they believe they would be condoning the takeover of the stone house. In an act of solidarity with the dispossessed, they are boycotting us, and denying us their sick bodies to treat. With so little to live for, there is nothing to inhibit their self-destructiveness."Our staff was divided as to whether we ought to force people who might have contagious diseases, like TB and SDV to come to treatment, or attempt an AIDS quarantine like the United Center had imposed in Central Africa, but Dr. Bari overruled our concerns by reiterating the primacy of the political aspect of our presence. "We do not have the solid footing to implement a policy of coercion at this time," he insisted.
Captain Mendez, after mulling things over for a while, agreed. He says that even though his well-armed platoon can easily handle any disturbances arising from the bairro dwellers themselves, he could not handle a guerrilla detachment infiltrated into the bairro and striking from under the cover of its disgruntled populace; and that the key to our security, from his point of view, is in not alienating the residents to the point where they might become active collaborators of the ERB. "They are stubborn as donkeys," he said. "Better that they kill themselves with TB than that we drive them into the arms of the guerrillas by trying to cure them." Nonetheless, Mendez arrested a young local this week, which did not in any way endear us to the bairro, or further his strategy. The man, by the name of Capoeira, was spotted near the stone house, slashing the air with a knife. According to Mendez, he was going through the motions of grabbing someone in an armlock from behind and slashing his pockets to take his wallet. Mendez believed the young man was a thief, who probably infiltrates downtown Rio, and that he was practicing his moves; our captain did not hesitate to detain him. According to irate locals, the boy was simply a harmless louco who played with his knife in order to feel more powerful, in the same way that kids pretend they are superman. One man said, "If he was practicing slashing someone’s throat, or stabbing them in the heart, you could arrest him, but he was only holding them by the wrist and slashing their pocket; what a tame fantasy! If he is a thief, he is a humanitarian. You should give him a medal for not wanting to kill. Your jails are too terrible for a boy so innocent, it would be like dropping a bomb on an ant. Just send him home to his mother."
"What do you mean ‘your jails’?" demanded Mendez. "They are ‘our jails’, yours and mine both, we belong to the same society and are ruled by the same government, and we both have a stake in punishing crime."
The man said: "Is there a law that says you can’t stab the air?" He walked away and some women who were standing nearby sang strands from a song: "Sow injustice, sow injustice, reap a hurricane. Crops of blood come from your greed. My tears will become a gun." Mendez had tears in his eyes, he felt helpless at that moment, and turning to Dr. Bari, said: "We’re surrounded. We’ve walked into a pit of vipers. Say your prayers, because who knows how this will all end."
Dr. Bari went out the next day to make a special effort to break through to the people. Some years ago, he had learned how to do origami from a Japanese nurse in Sao Paulo, and so he went about the neighborhood making shapes out of paper for the local kids. You should have seen the look on one mother’s face as he patted her child on the head. Like a rich man who discovers squatters trespassing on his property calls in the police, who beat the intruders with clubs and tear down their makeshift habitations, driving them, homeless, into the desert of a land that has no place for them, so her eyes called in the police of the poor: the spirits, demons, and winds that come to the aid of outraged hearts that have no tools with which to defend themselves in the world. She cursed the well-meaning doctor with her eyes; with her thoughts she stuck a hundred needles into his image
, and threw it into the flames. But she said nothing. After her child came back to her with the little bird Dr. Bari had made for him, she took it away and threw it into the air: "See, it don’t fly," she told her boy. "What kind of bird is that?" Dr. Bari thought, next, that we should give the people a feast at the stone house, but Captain Mendez said, "Are you kidding?, they won’t come. They won’t set foot in this house again unless we give it back to them. They’ll just smell all the good food cooking on the grill, and hate us for eating it while they’re hungry."Meanwhile, besides working on the drainage ditches, I have taken up the custom of helping Mina, who is the woman I first helped, in her daily chore of lugging the water-filled jug back from the well to her home. For the first few days, I was a laughingstock in the bairro. They called me "Mina’s pet." "Make him work for you. He’s going too slow, make him walk faster!" some of the other women joked. While the men said: "Be careful, you know what he wants! He wants to give you an injection with his ‘syringe
.’"One day she just turned around and asked me: "Why do you keep on helping me? You know, I have a man and he is in prison. You’re not the kind of man I like. I like men whose skin is even darker than my own."
"I’m just helping you, because you said it is hard to carry the water to your house. I’ve come to help. If nobody wants the services of a doctor, I’ll help in other ways." I told her that her house was wide-open with all kinds of cracks and holes. She needed air, she said. I offered her mosquito netting. She said it would make her feel like a fish being pulled out of the sea. I told her that her kids were beautiful, and that health was the world’s greatest treasure. I offered her a jar of quinine tablets, and a liquid vitamin formula in a vial with an eyedropper which boosts the immune system, which I explained to her means the body’s ability to defend itself. "Does it work against bullets? Against teargas? Poor Don Cristovao," she said. "Funny thing, white men dig the hole and throw you in, then give you a ladder to climb halfway out." I left the medicines behind on top of a chest of drawers without drawers on which she had left the plastic statue of a black virgin, seven candles, and a Bible, which she could not read, but put into her children’s hands whenever they were sick.
Every night in the stone house I withdraw from the others, who are increasingly attempting to fill in the void of our floundering mission with each other’s company, and I reflect: My compassion must not have motives! These people have an incredible sense of hearing, like a blind man, they can hear the pin of a motive dropping in another room; they will not lend their diseased bodies
, yearning for health, to political window-dressing, they will not cooperate in the expiation of a great sin by allowing the landslide that has buried them to apologize. What am I saying? I am in a place where the compasses in my heart no longer point to what I have learned. It is all very sudden, very disconcerting. I am losing my bearings in this hellhole which is the only logical product of the way I have lived until now, the equal and opposite reaction to the world I come from; all this reminds me of the day when I was nineteen, traveling across America to cure myself of wanderlust before the dawn of seriousness; the day, as a wild young man in search of himself, that I was traveling in the Colorado Rockies, riding my motorbike through the fog, when suddenly I could see nothing, not the mountain, not the road, nor the sheer cliffs which lurked on the side of the road, dropping off thousands of feet to the stone-filled valley below. There was nothing but fog as far as the eye could see, it was as if I had passed into another dimension and was no longer on the earth. I should have stopped, but I didn’t. I was young. Slowly, I nudged my bike along through the netherworld, through the mists that obscured everything except the sound of my beating heart which became the only thing I had to go by. Somewhere, right beside me it seemed, I heard the scream of an eagle. Had I, by becoming totally lost, joined him and become a creature of the sky? I feel, now, as I did then, that on all sides of me is a terrifying chasm into which I may fall – in this case, a moral chasm. Are there eagles here, or is there only fog?April 16
: I don’t want my compassion to come out as condescension. I don’t want my heart to be constipated, and to have to force love out of it. I don’t want to be fake. If I can’t love naturally, let me not love at all. If I can only hate these people, because they don’t fall for my fake love, let me hate them, let me scowl at them and look at them like they were bugs, just like the army. There is nothing worse than being a hypocrite. Sick people who will not even take our medicine – what have we done to them? I understand the economic and political theories, the reasons why places like this must exist, but it looks different at ground zero than it does in a book. Are there other kinds of doctors that this place needs, other kinds of medicine? Doctors who fix societies, medicines which heal nations? In our orientation, Dr. Chafing told us that population control is the key. The revolutionaries want to redistribute the wealth of the world, but there are too many people to redistribute that wealth to, it would be like trying to use your local duck pond to irrigate the Sahara; isn’t it better that there are many poor than that there are only poor? Anyway, think of Animal Farm. Why should we fold: so that the pigs can drink champagne while the horses continue to drag the plow? Dr. Chafing says Malthusian dynamics will smooth out the edges of the world system. Overcrowding will crash the human immune system in the Periphery; biological stressors will create rampant susceptibility, which, in part, explains the international AIDS epidemic and the appearance of new diseases. What hunger and disease do not do will be finished off by the wars fought between resource-hungry peoples; we must simply maintain a hard line regarding nuclear proliferation so that these wars do not contaminate the world at large. Revolutions will also erupt, exposing excess populations that the economy can no longer provide for, to the weapons of our allies, who will practice a new form of population control which utilizes helicopter gunships, machine guns, and cluster bombs. Regions which have rejected the idea of vasectomies will be sterilized by bullets. Once the population is trimmed, the system will be able to be more inclusive, and the call for rebellion will quiet. There really is no emergency, after all, once you get used to the idea of turbulence as a corollary of productivity in the context of scarcity, and keep a proper sense of detachment from the dying; once you cease longing for some stable, utopian "end of history" and become comfortable with the wild arcs of history, swinging like a pendulum back and forth between peace and war, and contentment and rebellion. There is no need to panic wondering "What will happen, what will happen, what can we do?!" Solutions are as inevitable as are the problems that make us seek them. Once you stop demanding that the solutions be pleasant, or soft, you will see how easy it all is. There is nothing to worry about as long as your heart is as hard as iron. Malthus had this all figured out, centuries ago.Besides Dr. Chafing’s presentation on Malthus, before our departure for Bairro Capanga, I remember a philosophy course I had back in college on the ancient Greeks. Heraclitus of Ephesus once said, in some ancient fragments found just in time for my graduation: "The chariot of the world is pulled by the horses of Strife… Struggle builds the world, peace asphyxiates it… Times whose roots do not reach deeply into the soil of strife give no blossoms to the world… A ship is made of wood; tranquility is made of war which is at rest." Maybe justice is only our means of trying to run away from history, and deny the inevitable.
I wonder why ideas that fit a few months ago now seem so uncomfortable, like clothes that have shrunk in the wash.
The medical staff is upset that we have not had a break yet, not the time off back in the secure zone which we were promised. We thought we would be allowed to spend weekends there. I used to think about Dirse, but missing her only makes me feel naked here. It’s better to have nothing to go back to. When you are in a dangerous place and you want to cry you know you have to change your focus.
April 18
: Today we went around with masks and gloves spraying for mosquitoes. "How come you’re wearing masks and gloves?" a woman asked us. "Shouldn’t we get some, too?" We explained about the dangers of the pesticide, but also calmed the people down about its effects if they did not come too close to it. "You aren’t mosquitoes, are you?" Captain Mendez asked. "Well, then, you don’t have anything to worry about." Somebody spread the rumor that we were spraying a chemical to make the people sterile, and Dr. Bari had to explain that that was not accurate. Still, no one has come to us for a vaccination or an exam. One of Captain Mendez’s men found a plot of Q2 beans on a hill behind some shacks. This is genetically patented stuff, and may have been obtained without a license, but he decided not to uproot it, because he now believes he doesn’t have enough men to safely deal with an uprising. "We’re walking on pins and needles here," he explained.April 19
: A furious man, waving his arms all around, confronted us in the morning about the spraying, claiming that we were using a chemical which made men impotent. It seems he could not satisfy his girlfriend the night before. "These people live in a universe of fantasies," Dr. Bari exclaimed. Again, we had to insist that the accusation was not true. Finally, a woman came to drag the man away, telling him that it wasn’t the spray, it was because his girlfriend was inexperienced. "Animals!" Captain Mendez said after they had left.Then, before the day had ended, an old man by the name of Joaquim came by. He is blind in one eye, which lacks an eyeball, and simply stares out into space like a white stone in his head, while his other eye he keeps half-closed as though he is afraid that some piece of dust will blow into it, rendering him completely blind. To top it off, he limps from arthritis in the knees, it seems. "Have you come for a medical exam?" I asked him, hopefully.
"Che is coming soon," he told me. "I can feel it. I know these things. Your days here are numbered."
"What’s this bull crap?" demanded Captain Mendez. "Che Guevara is as dead as a doornail."
"They made us another one," the old man said. "And he’s coming to kick you all out. Go on, shoot me, doesn’t the truth deserve a bullet?"
Some woman and her husband came up to lead Dom Joaquim away. "Don’t hurt him," they said, "he’s crazy." But then, as they were departing, the woman said, "He’s as crazy as Teiresias."
"Who’s that?" Mendez asked me. I guess I have the reputation of being the intellectual here, because once they found me reading a book in the dark.
I told him that Teiresias was a blind prophet mentioned in the Odyssey.
"Must be someone else," Mendez told me; "how would they know something like that? They can’t even write their own names."
April 21
: Today, I took a bold new step to end the isolation. I moved out of the stone house into a tent which I set up at a distance of about one hundred yards. Mendez was outraged and told me he couldn’t defend me that far from the house. In the night, he has the fence locked, the doors barred shut, the APC parked in front with a guard, and a man in the window and another on the roof. He also strings up trip wires across the path leading to the house, in lieu of mines, to slow down anyone who might think of rushing us in the night. But I explained my position to Dr. Bari: that we were viewed with hostility by the neighborhood, especially in view of the way that we had taken over the stone house; and that the only way to break down the barrier between us was to stop residing in that house, which had become a symbol of the injustice we had perpetrated and a symbol of the division that existed between us. We lived in the closest thing they had seen to a palace, while they lived in ramshackle shelters, in pits and ravines and hillsides. To them, we seemed only one more manifestation of the vast chasm that existed between rich and poor, and they despised our medicines as much as you would despise a few dollars thrown to you as compensation by a driver who had just run over your child.Dr. Bari decided to let me go ahead with my plan, since we were making no progress and I had the best record, so far, of getting along with the populace in view of my daily water-carrying for Mina. "Here, take this cell phone," he told me. "Press 1 for an emergency, and Mendez will come out to help. You already have a pistol. But please, try not to use it. Do you have a flashlight?"
I was amused by his concern, as if I were his son.
The others accepted my decision to move into the tent only because they thought it was a stratagem. If they had known that I am doing it as much for myself as for the success of our project, because I cannot bear the stress of feeling hated, and knowing that there is a good reason for me to be hated, then they probably would have said no. But perceiving me as a valiant manipulator, they are impressed.
April 30
: Well, quite a life I’ve had since the beginning of the tent. It’s made the world anew, like the invention of the wheel, or better yet, the lever, which took less effort, being nothing more than a stick lying around since the beginning of time which someone finally picked up and used. I have come to the conclusion that most of the great breakthroughs of history are only manifestations of the obvious.At first, the skepticism of the bairro dwellers wasn’t dented by my move out of the stone house. I guess if my home was a pile of dirt, and you just flew down from a cloud saying you wanted to help, I’d make you crawl across a field of broken glass before I’d trust you, too. Word is, in this bairro where nicknames gush into being like spring water from imaginations driven to states of hyperactivity by the poor fruits of reality, that the people began to refer to me as "The Farter." I was reputed to have left the stone house not because I was sensitive to the source of their rage, or because I wished to take a step closer to them, but because the others could not stand me and had driven me out. And the most demeaning reason they could come up with was that it was because I had a problem passing gas. Thus, my expression of solidarity, which might have necessitated a diminishment of their resentment towards me, which is dear to them and difficult to part with, was transformed into a comedy of grotesqueness, and I become even worthier of their contempt than before. "Wonder how long till they’ll let the stinker back in?" they joked with each other.
When Mina asked me one day, as I helped her with the water jug, why I was living in the tent, and I told her, a little curl of amusement appeared on her lips, a smile that had the cruelty in it of not wanting to reveal itself, and she said, "Now all you have to do is become black. Why don’t you try going back into the oven for a little bit longer? You’re undercooked." And she added, parroting the lyric of a popular song which parodies the promises of politicians: "Vote for me and I’ll give you a car of silver and a road of gold, and you can drive a hundred miles per hour to everything you never had."
With their barbs, they delighted in the possibility of exposing me as a sham and breaking what they thought were the weak legs of my gesture. One night, the thud of stones flying into my tent kept me awake. When I came out, I heard kids laughing, but saw no one. The next night, there was the howling of coyotes: the most unbelievable coyotes I have ever heard, who at times could not restrain themselves from giggling. The following night, a child of about ten came running to my tent, crying out for help, saying, "Doctor, doctor, come quick, my grandmother is dying, she can’t breathe!" I was so excited by the prospect of finally being able to help, and by the sudden dissolution of the barrier which had separated us from the populace until now, that I failed to register the child’s bad acting, and followed him blindly into the night with my medical bag until he suddenly disappeared in an arroyo, vanishing into the darkness with all the agility of a snake diving back into its hole. After searching for him for a moment, I realized that I had been made a fool of, and when I returned to my tent, I found that it had been cleaned out in the meantime. I lost my laptop, a watch, a flashlight, some personal supplies and clothing, some tins of food, a couple of books and some magazines, my sleeping bag, mosquito netting, and some extra syringes and medicines. Luckily, I had my journal in my medical bag, and took my pistol and my cellphone along with me. My tent had been in the process of being dismantled so that it could be carried away, as well, when I came back and the thieves, who I never saw because they must have posted a lookout, made off into the darkness. Surveying the disaster, I felt as though a great hole had been gouged out of me, as though I had been cut open and all my dreams of being a great humanitarian had been torn out of my chest and thrown onto the ground and stepped on
, and I was completely alone in the world with nothing at all to live for, and nothing else to be but that which I had tried to transcend. I stood, for a moment, at a terrible crossroads, with the emotional choice of abandoning my efforts, and returning with my tail between my legs to the stone house as an inferior version of Captain Mendez, or else sucking it up, and accepting the burden of paying for centuries of other people’s sins to become the person I wanted to be. What is more difficult for the caterpillar: to keep on growing wings, which hurt like being on fire, or to cut them off, and spend the rest of your life crawling when you know you could be flying? Finally, I remembered some words from the ancient Stoic philosopher, Epictetus: "Yesterday, a thief stole the iron lamp from my altar. If I could tell him something, it would be this: tomorrow, when you come, you will find an earthenware lamp in its place: for a man can only lose what he has." Wiser in the ways of the world, I decided to persevere.The next day, Mina said nothing to me and I said nothing to her as I carried the water for her from the well. I had the feeling that the whole bairro was watching me, looking for a sign of weakness. I was grim, but walked well, making sure that I did not appear humiliated. Swimming in shark-filled waters, not a single drop of blood can seep out of your wounds.
That night, the trials continued. No one felt sorry for me at all. There were several loud explosions right outside my tent, at first I thought it was a guerrilla attack. I slipped out, not by the tent flap, but underneath the back of my tent with my gun in my hand, to discover that it was a group of teenagers hurling high-powered firecrackers in my direction. The artificial bombs surged into being with a brilliant white color that seemed to want to devour the world, then exploded fiercely
, leaving behind a pungent smell that made the bairro seem like a battlefield. Angrily, I fired my gun above the teenagers’ heads and shouted: "That’s too much! Don’t push it!" They all bounded away like antelopes except for one who had something that looked like a tube of cardboard in his hands, who froze before he could run. "What, you came here to be our doctor, and now you’re going to shoot us?" he demanded."Sure," I told him. "No one’s coming to me to be treated. It looks like I’m going to have to make my own patients. Don’t worry, I’ve got plenty of bandages and disinfectant, and a forceps and scalpel, which they didn’t manage to steal last night, so I can remove the bullets from you - if they don’t pass all the way through, that is."
"Are you joking?" he asked me, disconcerting for his ability to believe that such a monstrosity was an option.
"That shit you’ve been shooting off tonight is too much," I told him, again. "I haven’t done anything to you. I can’t help it that I was born white. Is that a sin? I still believe in the things that seem absurd when they are betrayed: that race, religion, and nationality don’t matter, that we’re all human beings, and that when someone bleeds, it’s my duty to bind their wound. That crap you’ve been throwing tonight is as powerful as hand grenades, it could maim someone. Yes, I’ll shoot in self-defense if that shit’s thrown at me again. How far do you want to push things? I’ve come here to help, god damn it, but that doesn’t mean I’m going to wear a god damned crown of thorns. What, you think I’m going to shoot you in cold blood right now? Is that what you’re accustomed to?"
"Pretty much," the kid answered.
"Just go home," I said. "You know, by the way, that firecrackers like that are illegal, and you could do prison time for that?"
"They’ll never take me alive," he said, imitating some gangster or guerrilla or movie star, but completely meaning it in his juvenile way. "I won’t swim peacefully into the alligator’s jaws." That was from a song.
"No need to go down in a hail of bullets," I told him, "just put that crap away. Whatever you may think of me, I don’t deserve it."
At that moment, quite late I thought, my cell phone rang with Captain Mendez demanding to know if I was all right. They’d heard the firecrackers and hadn’t come out of the stone house because they thought it might be a major guerrilla attack. In fact, they now had every man up and all the pre
-set firing positions occupied, with the APC and jeep also manned and ready to roll into action, and a Predator on hold, back at base. I said, "It’s OK, no guerrillas, it’s just some kids being a pain in the ass and shooting off firecrackers.""If it’s really the guerrillas, and they’ve got a gun to your head, tell me one more time, Everything’s OK, it’s just kids shooting off firecrackers," he told me.
"No, really," I said. "It’s OK. You can all go back to sleep."
Then, turning back to the kid, I told him again to go back home. Smiling faintly, like somebody who feels better after puking, he backed away, then when he got to a ridge about eighty yards away, he turned around again and shouted, "Look at this one, doesn’t it look like an angel lighting a joint?" And he fired off a rocket which raced fizzling and hissing over my head, then erupted into a beautiful pattern of pink explosions that somehow made the vast night seem like it cared, like a house in the winter that has a fireplace. You can see stars filling the sky above Bairro Capanga if you dare to look up from the paths where you could be killed for a dollar.
After that momentous night, I graduated from being "The Farter" to "O Pistoleiro", the "Gunman." It was a step up in the world of Bairro Capanga, and a step closer to being "the Doctor." When I helped Mina with her water that morning, a group of young men, who seemed like they could be older brothers of the teenagers who had accosted me the night before, appeared on the side of the path and began to follow us. As they got closer, I put down the water jug.
"What happened, water weighs the same as always," Mina told me.
"My arm’s feeling sore," I told her. I was now free to draw my gun if needed.
The young men came up to us. "What’s wrong, Samson?" one of them asked. "You aren’t going to impress a lady like that, you’ve got to carry the water even if your arm breaks." They all laughed.
"You look strong," I told him. "Why don’t you carry the water for her?"
"My lady will get mad at me," he said.
His friend said, "Poor people got to learn to do things for themselves, too much handouts make them lazy." They knew all the rhetoric used against them.
The other guy said: "If she kisses me I will. How about it, Mina? Two kids hasn’t worn you out, yet. You look just as fine as before Roberto started dealing to keep you."
"Just move on, all of you," Mina told them, "and stop your probing. Put your dorsal fins back down."
"Help her with the water," one of the young men suggested, again.
"My arm hurts," I told him.
"Damn, this water’s heavy!" Mina protested, exasperated, not by me, but by the young men who had descended on us. "Go on," she told them, "move along, so he can get back to helping me. See, there’s something between shoot-on-sight and be a dumb-ass. Now go on, not every white man’s radar is broke!"
Shaking their heads, with strange souls halfway between panthers and clowns, they ambled on as though they were only out for an innocent stroll. They reminded me of cats who, failing to reach the top of a piece of furniture whose heights they have leapt for, walk away as though utterly disinterested. But their games could just as easily turn into hunts. All of us knew what had just transpired.
As I left her at her shack, Mina told me: "Don’t pay them no mind about what they said about Roberto. I never asked that man to do what he did. It wasn’t to keep me, it’s cause I wasn’t enough. He went and started to build his new world without me. And besides the crack, he killed a man who didn’t deserve it. He’s got life," she added. It was all pretty discreet and understated, but I wondered: did she actually care what I thought about her, to know that she was the kind of woman who wouldn’t use a man? And was there a reason that, although she had a man, as she told me when she first met me, she now wanted me to know that that was only in the most technical sense, and that, in actuality, he was no longer in the picture? And why did she tell me that he had killed a man who didn’t deserve it? To diminish his rights, in some way? To lessen his claim over her? To make the act of going with her, for the man who chose to do so, seem less an act of stealing her from a good man than an act of rescuing her from a bad one?
All night long, I could not sleep because of the few words she had spoken, my heart was pounding with excitement, guilt, and confusion. I love Dirse, I am sure that I do. She has been such a valuable counterpoint to everything I have learned, she has humanized the world I live in without driving me from it, made it possible to live on the bridge between Heaven and Hell without bearing the guilt of wings the rest of the world cannot have, or burning in the fire along with the damned. She has been challenging at every moment - mind-expanding, supportive, fun, and sexy, but most of all, she is vulnerable underneath her bravado - and the thought of hurting her by going with another woman is horrifying, like shooting into a crowd with a machine gun. But somehow, here, in Bairro Capanga, Dirse’s colors have faded. Her idealism seems bland, like food without spice, her passion too theoretical. She is utterly rambunctious, like a spirited pony, when placed beside businessmen, but here, she seems so tame, like a grandmother with her hair in a bun. But then, how was I only a month ago?
Mina, meanwhile, captivates me with her regal reserve and occasional smile that is like every flower in the world blooming at once. Something about her dark arms seems so vigorous, so fierce, so overpowering, like it could break you, and maybe that is what I want now, to be broken so that something that is stuck inside of me can come out. Or am I only being the typical man, looking for greener grass, craving an adventure? Is Dirse’s tan skin not dark enough to drown my whiteness in? I don’t want to break hearts, I don’t want to make mistakes.
Next morning, Mina didn’t give my world a chance to become more complicated. She acted utterly aloof, as though fleeing from her comments of the day before, and didn’t even say thank you. She, like everybody here, is wonderful at pretending. Wonderful at pretending that nothing happened: that no one robbed you, that no one wanted to mug you, that no one is sick, that there’s not drugs here or guns, that hints of something more than carrying a jug of water forever never took place. A meteor could land here and next day, as long as you were here to observe their reaction, people would just walk around the crater as if it had been here since the beginning of time. They will never let you know that they can be affected, because that would be giving away more of their power, and they have already lost too much. Mina’s not going to be a white man’s taste of dark meat any time soon…
At last, the decisive chapter in the Tent Chronicles occurred when the skies finally let loose with a burst of rain that took everyone by surprise, and sent the whole bairro rushing for its makeshift shelters as fast as it could run. Torrents and torrents came down from mid-afternoon all through the night and into the next morning. "Call Socrates, the carpenter," I heard one man calling to another. "Get him started building the boat." Sometimes, in this bewildering world, it’s hard to tell what’s a joke and what’s a mad idea that is actually believed with conviction. It wasn’t hard to imagine someone here beginning the effort to build an Ark and to gather up the chickens, goats, pigs and dogs wherever they could find them to sail away to a new world, just like in the Bible. I spent the day in my tent, as the water pounded the canvas ruthlessly, leaking in from an imperfection in a seam, then flooding in underneath the fabric, although I thought I had chosen the site well from the point of view of drainage, and turning my floor into a pool of mud. At one point, I had to go back to the stone house to get an entrenching tool, and with it, I dug channels to help carry some of the excess water away from the tent. At another time, in the middle of the night, as the wind howled like some kind of primeval beast hateful of humanity, I had to reestablish my tent which had fallen like a collapsed lung and buried me under its insufficiency. As I did so, the rain lashed into my face with a special joy, it seemed determined to rip away all our vanities, to strip us naked in the storm, to test our souls and spirits; as the poem said, "to make man savage again
." Literally with nothing on but my undershorts as all my clothes were by now completely soaked – and I would have taken my shorts off too but for the possible affront to the women of the bairro who were nowhere to be seen, stashed away in their own semblances of shelter, which did not prevent me from respecting them, however – I battled the elements to restore at least a vestige of protection. At last my tent was back up. I laughed to find myself as miserable as a wet cat, and thought that my tent was nearly as effective in fulfilling its purpose as the numerous social programs that had been invented to end poverty. What a strange, fierce storm! More aberrations of the weather? Well, as the Nomad Doctrine states, "The end of productivity merely to cut down on greenhouse gasses is patently absurd; nations with power shall migrate into the shells of underutilized regions to follow shifting patterns of fertility. Global climate change does not place limits on the existing powers, it simply encourages their mobility." So I guess little kinks in meteorology like this are no skin off the Center’s back. It will just pick up and move when circumstances demand.Next morning, as the skies cleared, and the rain faded away into merely a light patter on the canvas roof, I stepped out of my tent wrapped in a blanket, looking quite disheveled and mad, I imagine, as anyone who had lost a night’s sleep fighting against the windmills of the rain might appear. "He’s still here!" I heard someone saying.
"He went back to the stone house while it was raining."
"Just to get a spade. I saw him digging a drainage ditch."
"He spent the night in the stone house."
"No he didn’t, I saw him putting up his tent. It fell down. Look at him, does he look like he spent the night in the stone house? He looks like a drowned rat."
Pretending I hadn’t heard anything of their little conversation, I asked the people who were standing nearby how their shelters had held up in the storm. They just shook their heads as if to say everything was OK, which for them communicating with me, was actually quite loquacious.
Without really thinking it all the way through, my stubbornness has reaped tremendous rewards. The fact that I didn’t bolt from my tent during the storm to run back to the stone house seems to have convinced the people here that I am not fronting with them, but that I do have some sort of principles, after all. Now I have the feeling that they regard me as something utterly strange and exotic, like a unicorn, and they don’t quite know what to do with me.
Mina said, "Some storm last night. No need to carry the jug for me today, I put it out last night. Look how full it got, in spite of the narrow neck." I helped a few families improve the drainage around their shelters. They told me that under ordinary circumstances, their places hold up fine, but this was like being in "a tsunami", which is a kind of disaster they’ve only heard about, so that it’s easy for them to imagine that this was the same. One old man has been going around all morning with a fish saying that it fell from the sky. The others say he is crazy and tell him to stop carrying it around and to just cook it.
It is hard to believe, but this is a quantum leap.
May 2
: Captain Mendez was antsy all throughout May 1, which is a popular day for revolutionary action, but nothing happened. About the rain, he expressed satisfaction that some posters of Che Guevara which have begun to appear around the bairro had been washed away, "as though God, himself, wants to be rid of this Communist for good."This morning, I had the breakthrough I have been dreaming of since I came here. Mina showed up with a friend, Gabi, who has a very sick little boy who is obviously suffering from a severe gastrointestinal disorder, most likely a parasite. He is crapping the life out of him, is listless and utterly drained, and his skin is disconcertingly hot to the touch. A quick temperature reading showed that he was up to 105 F. I undertook treatment at once, which included emergency measures to decrease the boy’s temperature, an IV for fluids, injections of nutrients and antibiotics, and taking samples of the boy’s blood, urine, and feces for testing in our lab. The boy’s name is "Little Joao", and his mother kept on crying throughout the treatment, asking me, "Have I brought him in too late?"
A doctor’s skill lies not only in his medicine but in his presence. I told the mother, "You should have brought him sooner, but it is better that you brought him late than never. I will do everything possible to save him. I remain hopeful."
"Do you have a son?" she asked me.
"No," I admitted.
"Then you can’t imagine what it would be like to lose him," she told me.
"No one in this world, who’s lived more than a few years, hasn’t lost someone they love," I told her. "There’s no place in the world that’s free of pain. Some people build walls around their pain, to shut away everyone else’s. Some people build bridges from their pain to other people’s pain. I am a doctor, and that is the path I’ve chosen."
"Doctors want money, that’s all," Gabi told me, not impressed
. "Big cars, big houses, swimming pools: use sick people to buy it all for them. Highway robbery." Even though her child was in my hands, she couldn’t keep from blurting out her feelings."If I wanted money, I would be back in the US," I told her.
"That’s right," Mina said, "he could be reeling in the dough doing liposuction for those dinosaurs that eat everything we don’t have. If he’s here, he must want to do something."
"Probably failed the medical school. They sent him here cause nobody with money wanted him anywhere near them. Not with a scalpel in his hand. Not over their heart."
"Some people want to help people," Mina protested. "Once you stop believing that that’s possible, what’s left? For every hundred outsiders who are con artists, there has to be one who’s for real. There can’t be nothing but rotten eggs in the world, or the word ‘rotten’ wouldn’t exist. We’d just say ‘eggs.’"
"Huh?" Gabi asked.
"Give him a chance," Mina insisted.
May 4
: Little Joao is going to make it. It was a scary couple of days. He came to me on the verge of death, just a few hours from shitting himself out of existence. If on a planet the size of the earth there was nothing alive except a single mouse, that’s how much life was left in the body of Gaby’s baby when she finally decided to bring him to me. I don’t write this to brag. I didn’t save Little Joao, modern medicine did. In the same way, it isn’t a bacterial parasite which nearly did him in, it is a world which utterly ignores places such as Bairro Capanga, and allows them to become breeding grounds for diseases which the rest of the world did away with years ago. The pitiful condition of the child under my care, so gratuitously inflicted, outraged me. I felt both fury and tenderness as I worked to save him. Like the rain that pounded the bairro only a few days ago, penetrating every barrier devised to resist it, there was no shelter from his mother’s despair.Throughout the treatment, I was impressed by Gabi’s devotion to her son. She would not leave his side, not to go home, not to sleep or to eat. Mina had to make her food and bring it to her. She also brought her a blanket, with which she covered her. Nothing I could say could induce Gabi to desert what she felt was her post. "In case anything happens, I have to be right here," she said. "I can hold his hand and pray. I can bring him back, or send him on a boat of roses into the next world." In fact, her prayers began to drive me nuts, but who was I to tell her to stop, even as they began to bounce around inside my head like the maddening echoes of a million people saying the rosary. At other times, she would sing the sweetest of lullabies, a beautiful melody with the words: "Baby don’t go nowhere
, till Mamma leads the way." It was amazing, she hardly knew this child - he hadn’t been in the world long enough to know in any real sense - and yet she stood by him with the utmost loyalty and passion, as though she had known and loved him for a thousand years and as though that much history of togetherness was at stake. And I thought: kids like Little Joao are a dime a dozen; all over the world they are dying like flies, thousands of them every day. Does every one of them have a mother like this? Is that much grief radiating from our planet? Carbon dioxide radiating from our factories can change the climate of the world; what about all these tears?By the end of it, six or seven women were hanging out in my ramshackle clinic along with Gabi, holding candles and joining her in prayer and song. They looked like a band of angels who had forgotten to erase their dark faces in recognition of where the power lies. For even Heaven obeys the strong.
May 7
: Today Gabi got Little Joao back with some medication in the form of droplets, and a series of follow-up visits planned. She gave me a huge hug, then made the sign of the cross and bowed at the waist, something between a religious devotee and an actress who has just given a great performance; and several of her friends touched me. Mina said, "Well, finally you’re the doctor you came to be."I said, "Finally you let me be."
May 15
: Things have been going forward at a tremendous pace ever since Little Joao’s recovery. It’s like a dam had broke, and a flood of people with all sorts of ailments, some terrible and life-threatening and others merely fantastic products of hypochondria, has come surging my way. At once, I struggled to bring the rest of the civic action team in on the development, and to get the people of the bairro to utilize the more substantial facilities in the stone house since my tent is underequipped and overwhelmed by their numbers, but the people will not go to the house that was taken from them. Instead, they have agreed, only after much pleading on my part, to accept visits in their own homes from some of the other doctors, but only if I am unavailable; and a woman named Eva, with the help of neighbors, is rearranging her cavern-like home in the side of a hill to serve as an expanded facility for my activity. We will put a couple of beds in there, and store some equipment, which will be guarded 24/7 by some young men who may belong to the Quilombolas, one of the gangs here that is favored because it does not prey upon its own. If you were to draw a parallel from the animal kingdom, it would not be a tiger that stalks men, but a poison snake that bites only those who step on it. As a sign that my situation in the community had now radically transformed, as I came out of the tent one morning I discovered some of the items that had been stolen from me returned, left outside of my tent flap with a note written in the most wretched Portuguese: "Compootor gon nau, tu lat. Sold all redi. We traid for u, tu lat. Sori. Mak things rit, ani hau." In the envelope in which I found the note, apologizing for the fact that my computer was not among the returned items, was some money - only a small amount and far from the cost of the missing lap top - but a gesture, at least; and on the bill was written: "Sori, all thats lef."At that moment, I felt like the luckiest man to ever live.
When, jarred and moved by the disparity between the intentions and competence of the letter I had received, I asked Mina if she thought the bairro might be interested in connecting to a literacy program, in addition to the medical program which it had already been offered, she said, "Why not? We got a lot of things to write to the President about. Now he throws our letters out, because he can’t understand them. After we learn to write better, he’ll throw our letters out because he does." Sensing that I wasn’t sure what her final take on the subject was, she smiled and said, "That’s an improvement." We’ve put in a call to the Department of Education’s Literacy Campaign, which, is, in fact, the program Dirse is working with while I’m in Bairro Capanga.
True to expectations, now that the neighborhood has finally opened its door to us, it turns out that there are all kinds of maladies tearing up the place. Several individuals have tested positive for TB, and we are medicating them and working on establishing a hygiene protocol that this community can live with, since none of the sufferers wants to be removed to a sanatorium, and forced extraction from the community seems counterproductive from the political point of view. We are confronting widespread symptoms of intestinal boreworm infection, which is highly treatable with appropriate medications, and we are simply awaiting lab results. Several varieties and stages of respiratory affliction and bleeding through the urinary tract may be related to opportunistic infections facilitated by AIDS. More testing is being conducted. Poor nourishment is also a major factor in debilitating the immune system, and contributing to these types of pathologies. And then, there are the SDV cases. Where AIDS is involved in the background, treatment will be arduous. Where it is not present, a regimen of medications, some taken orally, and others applied as salves to the affected areas, may drive the symptoms beneath the surface, leaving a condition similar to herpes which passes through dormant and active periods, but which will not degrade and lead to massive, irreversible disfigurement. In my tent, I treated 3 cases which were not severe, and one man who is still known as "Face", because of his handsome visage, but who underneath his shirt is a morass of hideous sores and puss. Working on him was messy business. Though I detest using a mask and gloves for psychological reasons, cases of doctors in Africa who have wished to express solidarity with Ebola sufferers by refusing the protective barriers which separate them from their patients, have only succeeded in proving that there is a great difference between solidarity and sentimentality. From saliva, blood, and/or particulates of mucus sprayed their way, they caught the very disease they were attempting to eradicate, and were lost, along with their critical expertise, in the midst of a sea of hands crying for help. Afterwards, I talked with Dr. Bari about improving our ability to safely do away with biological wastes.
By far the most distressing case of SDV which I have had to deal with so far involves a woman named Maru, who used to be a great beauty they say, but whose face has now been utterly ravaged by the disease. Her man, in fact, who had been away working as a laborer in Maranhao, and who they thought might never return, did return one day, only to drive her out of the house as soon as he saw what had become of her. Now she lives alone in a little cave which the self-proclaimed priest of the town, Brother Lazaro, made for her before he died. Brother Lazaro had actually worked for the church once, but the official priest of Bairro Capanga, before he fled from the neighborhood due to the unruly nature of the people, had succeeded in initiating the procedures which resulted in Brother Lazaro’s excommunication. Brother Lazaro, it seems, had some strange aberrations of belief: for example, he preached that Maria Magdalene was Jesus’ wife, and that Jesus by her had a son, of whom he, Brother Lazaro, was a descendant; he also believed that Judas killed Jesus, not for gold, but because Jesus chose peace on earth before justice on the earth, and that now the spirits of Jesus and Judas have merged into one to form the complete savior. Brother Lazaro called them two halves of the same soul, the day and night that need each other. The bottom line is that he was a liberation theologian, and that went out of vogue years ago.
After Brother Lazaro’s kindness, Maru was essentially left on her own, brought food by her mother and shunned by everyone else. One night, when she tried to go back home, her man got up out of bed where he was lying with another woman and chased her away with a machete. The woman he was with threw stones at her. Mina told me: "It would break our hearts except she looks so bad it dries our tears up. It’s like seeing a ghost, you just get the most awful chills and want to run away."
"Once you lose the will to remind yourself that someone else is a human being, it isn’t hard to drive them away and make them live in a cave," I said.
Mina knew what I meant. "Are you saying she’s the Bairro Capanga of Bairro Capanga? So if we go to her, the world is going to come to us? Well, go on, then, see her. But don’t get yourself sick. Wear your mask."
For them, Maru is like a fire-breathing dragon, if she exhales you will be poisoned by the mist of her disease, if her teardrop falls on you, it will burn through you like acid, if she coughs, you will become her twin, if she touches you, it will be like making love to a cadaver at the bottom of a grave. Since their knowledge is imprecise, they protect themselves with the severest of boundaries. Not knowing whether they face a house cat or a lion, they dig a moat deep enough and wide enough to keep a lion away. I, being a doctor, with precise knowledge, can come closer.
It was, nonetheless, with awful trepidation that I let Maru’s mother guide me to her outcast daughter’s cave, while Mina and a member of the Quilombolas stood a good fifty yards back. It took a great deal of coaxing from her mother to finally get her to step out of the cave into the light where I could see her face. What a disaster! Her face was a barely recognizable mess of bloody sores, with her right cheekbone exposed by the flesh that had fallen off; it was nearly formless, without definition, like the face of someone found at the site of a terrible auto wreck after flying through the windshield, except that there were two plaintive, angry eyes looking out from beneath it all, signs of life crying for help, but not expecting it. I could tell she was waiting for me to withdraw in horror. Even her mother was averting her eyes. I admit, at that moment I forced myself to a new level of bravery. But I knew within that awful wreckage was a soul: a soul that could not have forgotten the taste of life. I was very focused and businesslike, it was the only way I could control my emotions, but for her, even though I was well-shielded by my mask and gloves, and acted as a doctor and not a saint, it was as if I were Jesus kissing her on the forehead, curing her of abandonment. I looked at her not with disgust or pity, but with compassion and professional attentiveness. I ask myself, since it was such a struggle, how? I believe it is like adjusting a showerhead, a showerhead of emotions inside your soul. If the spray is too wide, your first instinct of revulsion will come out and your ideal of love will express itself as sugary pity, offensive to the patient, since it is really only the manifestation of revulsion overpowering love and hijacking it; if the stream of emotions is too narrow, on the other hand, you will come off as cold, purely a technician, and the patient will feel despised like a frog that is being dissected. But if you find the right width of emotions within your soul, you will have compassion without pity, professionalism without coldness, respect for the disease without terror, love for the patient without affect. The adjustment happens in a moment, and is not fundamentally intellectual; it is very nearly physical, in fact, something like what the lens of the eye does as it searches for just the right level of tension to bring an object into focus.
The mere fact that I was able to deal with Maru in this way - to cleanse her wounds, to use the lancet, to disinfect the sores, to do some scraping, to apply medicinal salves, to place bandages, to give injections of antibiotics, to dispense pills and spare bandages, and to take blood samples for AIDS testing, without displaying either horror or the selfish ambition to use her as my ticket to Heaven - was overwhelmingly healing for her. The treatments will continue. Depending on the results of the AIDS testing, she will either be sent to our civic action affiliate hospital in Rio proper for more elaborate treatment, or else worked on here by Dr. Soares, who will do a patch-up procedure on the right side of her face, until the situation is stabilized to the point where it will make sense for her to undergo a more substantial program of reconstructive surgery. This might be arranged through the International Program for the Support of Battered Women’s surgical team, since the civic action budget considers plastic surgery, except in the case of landmine-related incidents, to be beyond its scope.
The day after my first visit with Maru, my overpowering stream of patients dried up. "I’m glad to see no one’s sick today," I told Mina. "But we must begin to screen all the kids here, beginning with your own. We’ll need physical exams, along with blood, urine, and stool samples, to test for various diseases and parasites and also to get a picture of where we stand with regard to nutritional issues."
"There’s people sick today," Mina told me. "They just don’t want to come and see you. They’re afraid now that you’ve been treating Maru, you might have the SDV on you
, and pass it on to them. They like you and don’t want to hurt your feelings by letting you know what they’re thinking, so they’re just staying away."Knowing this, I called a meeting, which a good number of people showed up for, and I explained to them how SDV is transmitted and how it is not transmitted. I explained to them what procedures I had used to protect myself, to dispose of or clean my clothing, and to disinfect and wash myself in the wake of treating Maru. "Granted: nobody wants to be bitten by a cobra," I said. "But what would you say if, to avoid the possibility of being bitten by a cobra, you spent your whole life flying in an airplane above the ground? Wouldn’t you call that exaggerated? Well, that is, essentially, what you are doing now. Maru is not the homem-marinho," I told them, referring to a mythical creature which some poor Brazilians still believe in, a sea monster that murders people on the beach, devouring their fingers and genitals before disappearing back into the ocean. "She is one of you," I said. You must protect yourselves from the contagious disease which she carries, but you do not have to sever her from your world. You can be safe from her, without throwing her away. I will tell you how."
The people listened with interest to my explanation. Then one man, skeptical, as most of the residents, of any form of official information, said, "Doctor, we are now beginning to understand that you are a sincere man. But where do you get your information from? Are you sure it is not from some government agency? We feel they do not want the people to know the truth, and that, in fact, when they tell us we cannot get a disease in such and such a way, it is because they want us to be careless and get the disease in exactly that way, so they can finally be rid of us. They are using biological warfare against us, and their strongest weapon is misinformation."
Without dismissing his fears, I told him that various independent studies had produced this information, which I had read in medical journals during my studies, and that I believed them. The fact that I disagreed with the studies in one detail, regarding the assumed longevity of the SDV agent outside of the body, which I believed might, in fact, survive even longer than supposed, pleased my audience immensely, and boosted my credibility.
I was then asked for my opinion on the reliability of Erva Acari for preventing AIDS. This is a supposed miracle drug which the media in the Center views as a product created by the poor and embraced by the poor, in a land where mysticism and backwardness reign. What people in the Center don’t know is that Yerba Acari - with some beneficial anti-inflammatory properties, but utterly unsuited to tackling HIV or cancer - is big business in the Amazon, and that it is controlled by multinationals operating out of the Center. They are deliberately marketing it in areas of extreme desperation, areas which are medically deprived, such as this one, where the people spend extravagant percentages of their income to acquire it as a shield against terrible diseases which it cannot resist. It is now common, in many areas, for people to mix Yerba Acari into a drink before making love, doing so in the belief that it will protect them from AIDS even if their partner is infected.
Without wishing to devastate those who might already have used the drink, given the fact that disillusionment from the placebo effect can sometime produce catastrophic crashes in the immune system (Jackson 2002; Rodriguez 2018), I nonetheless provided the sternest warning possible against the use of Yerba Acari as an AIDS preventative. In fact, its tendency to thin the blood, leading to an increase in instances of the commonplace and small-scale hemorrhaging which ordinarily accompanies sexual acts, increases the possibility of the spread of AIDS. I stated, for the benefit of all concerned, that an AIDS awareness workshop ought to be conducted as soon as possible, and I promised that I would do everything possible to make sure that we were able to obtain, from our program, up-to-date and effective drugs for containing the HIV virus.
In the same spirit as before, someone said: "Don’t accept any of that crap they already banned in America. All that stuff they won’t throw out because they don’t want to lose money, so they send it to us. Don’t give me a pen knife to fight the tiger when the rest of the world is using guns."
I assured him again that I would do my best to make sure that we got a competent AIDS prevention and treatment plan up and running here.
At the end of this week, I had a case of a different kind, an old man whose mouth was filled with rotting teeth. There was nothing I could do but pull them, then give him an injection of antibiotics and send him away with a bottle of antiseptic mouthwash. As I pulled his teeth, he exclaimed, "Jesus Christ, you should be working for the CIA! I would tell you everything I know."
"Sorry," I said. "I’m a doctor, not a dentist."
He said: "I thought they were the same."
May 20
: More progress. Eva’s cave finally became available, and my new medical station has been moved inside of it. The lighting is dependent on candles and a small hole in the hill side which sends a single ray of light in around 3 PM, which lasts for about fifteen minutes, all of which gives the place the look of a religious shrine much more than of a medical facility. A statue of Jesus has been inserted into a nook in the wall, beside the image of some African goddess, and the sick lay offerings of fruit, coffee, and even elaborate meals which they have prepared, at their feet, so as to gain the best of both worlds: that of modern medicine, and that of the world that developed in its absence. I am not sure which, for them, is the tightrope, and which is the safety net. Since the lighting does not serve at all for making informed diagnoses or performing any complicated procedures, I have had a small, gas powered generator – properly vented, of course - brought in which can be turned on to light a powerful lamp when called for; and an outdoor examination area, hemmed in by curtains, has also been set up for fair weather days, so that natural lighting can be exploited whenever it is available. Besides this, I have a hand-held light which an assistant can hold for me. What the cave does have is beds, a table, some equipment and supplies, and most of all, the acceptance of the people who are willing to embrace it as a part of their community. The hygiene is obviously substandard compared to a conventional clinic or a hospital, but we are taking the issue seriously and doing the best we can. My efforts to convince my colleagues to abandon the stone house in order to restore one half of it as living quarters for bairro residents, while utilizing the other half as a more substantial clinic than the one I have just opened, have been rejected due to security considerations. According to Mendez, we cannot "give up the stone house", because we need a dependable and defensible base, especially during the night time: more so than ever, now, in view of several recent news developments.The mounting problems presented by the Che legend led World Justice, this week, to interrogate Dr. Johansson, the alleged creator of the Che clone, in Sweden, and to impound his laboratories and archives. Under maximum binding vows – that is, with perjury punishable by death, not only applicable to the perjurer but also to his family and friends – he admitted to the fact that he did, indeed, create a Che clone 29 years ago, which was raised for a brief time in Sweden. He lost track of the child after three years, when it was given to handlers whose plan was to raise it in an unspecified foreign country, before sending the young man on to a revolutionary training program that would be both military and political in nature. However, according to Dr. Johansson, something had obviously gone wrong, because a contact from the "life preparation group" came back to him a few years later, asking him to make another Che clone. According to Dr. Johansson, the contact would not say, specifically, what the problem was, but Dr. Johansson had the feeling from how he behaved that the operation had somehow been compromised by international intelligence agencies, or rent asunder by an internal dispute, and that the Che clone had been "dumped" like stolen goods until things cooled down, probably into some orphanage; and that when the handlers had come back to recover him, he was gone, already given away, and they could not pick up his trail. Dr. Johansson was unable to grant the contact’s request to make another clone, because, in the meantime, his genetic sample of Che had become degraded through improper storage.
According to Mendez, this is the worst possible development that could happen: encountering proof that the maddening legend has an actual basis in fact, without encountering Che, himself, so that he can be neutralized. All throughout the Periphery, and most especially in Latin America, in spite of official news quarantines, the word is out, and the mood is growing wilder by the minute: ominous and jubilant, with the threat of extreme violence mixed in with the revelry. "We are living," according to Colonel Bradley, back at base, "in a hybrid moment that is a cross between the Carnival and the impending eruption of a volcano." You wouldn’t know it from here, in Bairro Capanga, where we have been making extraordinary progress. But in Fortaleza and in Salvador, there have been riots, replete with furious crowds brandishing placards of Che and Molotov cocktails, and several tanks have been burned; in Uberlandia, a formidable military base was infiltrated by guerrillas, who passed through its minefield, no doubt thanks to inside information, and surprised several attack helicopters stationed there before they could be flown away; then, with a group of well-trained pilots, they flew two of those captured helicopters to the army base at Sao Paulo do Norte, and, before anybody could figure out who was who and what was what, they opened fire on the defenders, who were simultaneously assaulted by a guerrilla column on the ground. At the same time, urban commandos blew up a police station in Sao Paulo itself, and knocked out a power station. Although Sao Paulo do Norte held, it was in a state of crisis for nearly a day, and the whole region has been badly shaken. Even worse, the guerrilla column does not seem to have been destroyed during the withdrawal phase, as its daring warranted; in fact, it seems to have the capability to simply disappear back into the countryside after striking its blow, in spite of the fact that its support networks were supposed to have been uprooted by the paramilitaries over a year ago. Finally, as if this were not enough, an American Forest-Protection Colony in Rondonia was overrun just two days ago. The ERB seems to have come back to life with a vengeance
.I told Captain Mendez, as the civic action team held an emergency meeting in the stone house, that it is useless to proclaim victory in the Periphery when the source of the war remains. It is as useless as bailing the water out of a ship while doing nothing about the hole in its side. One generation of guerrillas is destroyed, but another grows in its place. Repressive terror quiets the world until injustice overcomes the fear, and foolishness is resurrected. And once again there are men who, with bare chests, will face bullets because the blood of those who died in vain is dry, and the blood of those they love is still fresh. "I am surprised by how amazed you are at the ERB’s recovery," I said, "which parallels everything we know about the nature of disease. When you treat the symptoms and not the cause, your victories are doomed to be ephemeral."
"This is why we are here," admitted Captain Mendez.
"Are we repairing the dike, or merely putting our finger in the dike?" I asked him.
"Sometimes," he said, "the world is saved by a gesture."
I agreed, but added: "Gestures are also dangerous. They awaken ideals which were asleep. Then, like passengers whose legs have been cramped all night long as they sit in tiny seats on a train, these ideals want to get up and walk around. They want to get off the train and go out into the world. When expectations are raised, the possibility of disappointment is also raised. Gestures always seem more significant to those who do not depend on the substance which has been invoked by them. The effect of gestures can be overestimated. The people love them because they think that something more is meant to follow. If there is nothing after, the gesture becomes worse for them than a water cannon sprayed into their face
.""Your point, doctor?"
"We need to be real, Captain. Bairro Capanga needs to be more to us than a speed bump we are attempting to construct across the highway of revolution. These people need to be more to us than mere neutron rods, inserted into a nuclear reactor core to prevent a meltdown. We are living among mothers, fathers, sons, daughters, uncles, aunts, nephews, nieces, cousins, lovers, neighbors - our human brothers and sisters."
I think I sometimes have the tendency to give sermons and that I provoke resentment on account of it, especially when I demand, from people, things they lack the inner power to give. People have always said I have the tendency to get carried away by my passion. If I think it is right to live on the moon, I will try to do it, even though it is impossible, even if it means I will be left completely alone, dwelling in a crater. They have compared me to Don Quixote, charging windmills with his lance. Or am I being self-flattering? In the end, I am merely stubborn, not idealistic. It is Dirse who has pushed me in this direction, then lagged behind. No, I have moments of unreasonable romanticism, but thus far have always returned to common sense. My heart throws itself against limits, like a wild horse on a rope that wants to be free, but my mind understands limits; it is, in fact, the rope. All I know is that I felt acutely uncomfortable there, among my fellow doctors and Captain Mendez’s soldiers, as though I were asking them all to jump off a building and fly, and leaving them no choice but to do that or to have devil’s horns. No wonder I yearned to go back out into the bairro as quickly as possible , to escape their silent, offended faces. And I am sure they were waiting with equal fervor for my departure.
As far as I can tell, the highlight of the meeting was when Captain Mendez expressed relief that two civilian contractors who were found at the edge of the bairro with bullets in their heads had merely been killed by bandits, and not the guerrillas. "Thank God!" he exclaimed. How precise our humanity has managed to become; how exact our cues for grieving!
Meanwhile, in medical news, I conducted an AIDS awareness workshop which was so well attended that it made me feel like Peron or Gaitan giving some fiery populist speech in the plaza, although all I was doing was imparting technical medical information; I actually needed a microphone and amplifier to finish. At the end, free condoms, immune-enhancers, post-exposure response meds, and informational pamphlets based principally on diagrams were distributed. The day before, a truck had rumbled up from the secure zone filled with supplies, a Pawnee A-37 attack helicopter cruising the skies above it. One teenager laughed, and said: "Don’t anybody try to take our condoms, or we’ll blow you up!" The thought of protecting a shipment like that with violent force amused the neighborhood beyond words.
May 23
: Incoming results are showing massive numbers of bairro residents are HIV Positive. Our treatment program for all other conditions will have to be designed to take into account the compromised immune systems of many of our patients. I am speaking to the people in realistic, yet spirited terms, about all this, so that they do not succumb to panic.Although the bairro has no formal chamber of commerce or civic action junta, an unofficial council comprised of some of the more active citizens, members of the Quilombolas, and some who are considered "elders" is taking shape to help integrate our projects into the community. Together, we will continue the program to eradicate mosquitoes – test results are also beginning to return showing the prevalence of malaria, which is another immune-system-depressor; in addition, we will attempt to cover over and isolate the effects of open sewage systems which present a major health hazard, especially to some residents. The long-delayed program of childhood vaccinations is going to start soon, and a massive video screen for long-distance literacy training is going to be installed, since the Department of Education believes this location is far too dangerous to insert its personnel into.
Speaking of literacy, yesterday I discovered a most amazing, and moving thing. First of all, to put it all in perspective, Mina has two beautiful kids, a boy of eight and a girl of six. The boy’s name is Helder. He was named after the famous liberation theologian of bygone days, Helder Camara, the Bishop of Recife, who once said: "When I fed the poor they called me a saint. When I asked them why there were poor, they called me a Communist." He had sought to use the gospels as a basis for the nonviolent transformation of Brazilian society and the defeat of poverty, which starts with the indifference of one class of men towards another, and from his point of view, is a result of the failure of men who call themselves Christians to live up to their faith. Mina, though a Christian in her own eccentric way, named her boy Helder, not in honor of a priest, but in honor of a man who fought for the poor. Her daughter was named Zenobia, after the Middle-Eastern warrior queen who battled against the Romans, and made that mighty empire quake. When I discovered, in Mina’s shack, a stack of charming children’s books, filled with pictures, which she must have made a great effort to obtain over a number of years, I exclaimed, "How thoughtful of you, to get these for your kids!"
"What do you mean?" she asked. "I got them for me. I mean, we look at them together, now, but I got some of them before they were even born."
"When you were a kid?"
She glared at me, then just shook her head and went on doing what she was doing.
And I stood there, stunned, suddenly realizing my terrible social gaffe, and the terrible plight of this highly intelligent, deeply curious woman, who had never learned to read. So she had taken the only books that she could make any sense out of, the ones with pictures in them to stir her imagination and serve as keys for opening the stories that were locked shut behind the padlock of her illiteracy. In this way, she broke, like a burglar, into the world of Gulliver’s Travels and the Arabian Nights, Aesop’s Fables and the Greek Myths, Pinocchio and pirates, the history of her country, and the crafts and culture of Africa. In this desert, without the water of written words, she survived like a cactus, refusing to let her mind die from neglect. But the hurt of deprivation was plain to see in her eyes. She knew she was missing a leg, and that in other parts of the world, people were dancing.
I told her: "Your kids will read, Mina. And you, too."
She kept on doing what she was doing.
May 25
: The atmosphere intensifies. Now, in Rio, itself, in the Penultimate Zone, that is, just two levels out of the Secure Zone, a major demonstration demanding an end to foreign colonization and forced labor migrations took place, replete with placards of Che and banners saying, "He’s Back!" The army, out in force, let it go on for a few hours in order to better gauge the dimensions of the rebellious sentiment, before finally legging loose with canisters of tear gas. The diehards who persisted even after the gassing - a handful of masked agitators, some of whom were armed with more than stones - were treated to a dose of live ammunition, until the streets were again calm, if, indeed, the term has any merit in the middle of "hurricane season." According to Captain Mendez, Brazil, as well as many other parts of Latin America, is sitting on a powder keg.All of this has led me to wonder: what is it that brings about a revolution? A man or a condition? A leader or a situation? Why should these people who live constantly in a state of poverty, lashed by hardships that the rest of the world has left behind, stung by awful limitations in the shadow of other people’s opportunities – opportunities not only to possess, but to squander, and to decadently misuse – care, at all, about the clone of Che? What can he possibly do for them that they cannot do for themselves? He is one man. They are billions. It is their backs which bear the whip marks of injustice, and only their backs which can carry the weight of making a new world. What do they need him for? It seems, he should be as superfluous to them as an insect crawling on the back of an elephant. And yet, his picture is everywhere, his name is in their chants, his fiery eyes are in their hearts, the thought of him standing beside them is what gives them the courage to pit the armor of human flesh against the steel of tanks. In some ways, though they are great and he is small, he towers above them! What is this all about? Is it the natural reaction to years of destruction, this utter lack of confidence that requires a savior, something stronger and greater than they feel they are? A god, resurrected from defeat, and made invincible by the flowers they have laid on his grave? Though they are the ones who must move the earth, have they been conditioned to feel so incapable that they are willing to believe that one man not tainted by the sin of submitting to a gun, can do what they, in all their vast numbers, cannot do? Do they truly believe that this Che is a genius, an Einstein of the bullet, an Archimedes of flowing red blood? Or the prophet of a God, like Moses or Jeremiah? That something he knows or thinks or can conceive of can overcome the odds, overthrow the rule of firepower, which is the master of billions of pounds of flesh
, with some esoteric insight, teach the wheat how to break the scythe? Or is he merely a reminder of what lurks within them, a spark to ignite the endless, dry forest that has the power to burn, but not the confidence to start burning? Is he merely a part of them, the one atom that can move the rest?The people are poor, desperate, and angry, and yet, they are afraid and confused. Somehow, when they raise the placard of Che above them, their fear fades away, they stare like him into the face of that which oppresses them with his bold eyes, with the savage pose of his gentleness. From his hand, only, they will take the rifle they have feared to hold for all these years: the rifle that breaks the hypnotic bond between dominant and submissive, that erases the boundaries of safety and makes the world dangerous again, which means, once more, that seeds can grow. Creation is being revisited. The first age belonged to jaguars, the next to birds, the next to monkeys; maybe this one will belong to men.
May 28
: Today marks another watershed. I already thought I was accepted by the community, but each time I think this, another level of acceptance is unveiled and I realize I have merely been a dearer form of outsider.Today, Mina asked me to go with her to the garbage-dump-mountain that looms, in the distance, above the bairro: "Pearls to Swine." Of course, it got its name from the Bible, the part about casting your pearls to swine. It seems that poor people from around here, either from this neighborhood or from others nearby, gave the mountain that name in a simultaneous act of cynicism and awareness, which encoded both their knowledge of how the world viewed them and a statement of how, in order to survive, they were forced to transform worthless things
, which the rest of the world had discarded, into treasures, like pearls. The government, itself, refers to "Pearls to Swine" as "Urban Refuse Station Number 6", or, when it wishes to be more informal, as "the Garbage Mountain."It all happened very simply, Mina coming up to me at the end of a screening clinic for children, to ask me if I would go with her. "Tomorrow is the convoy," she told me, simply. "Will you join me at Matthew 7:6?"
"What are you talking about?" I asked her. "Are you inviting me to a Bible study group?"
She laughed and said: "No, to the mountain," and she pointed to the ominous, grayish-black mound rising up in the distance. "The garbage trucks are coming tomorrow with a big load. Probably about noon. We’ll start out at dawn from Colina dos Bluns so we can get there on time."
"How do you know the trucks are coming?" I asked her.
She said: "How does a horse find water?" And she added, "Don’t forget to bring your gun."
When I told the civic action team about my plans later that afternoon, they unanimously urged me to reject the invitation. Captain Mendez, the most vocal critic of the idea, told me: "You must realize by now that our civic action program, which is finally, in large part thanks to you, beginning to achieve popularity here in Bairro Capanga, is undercutting the revolutionaries. If the people see that the quality of their lives can improve without the desperate measure of resorting to violence, they will stay on the side of the government; why provoke repression when they have the hope of bettering their lot without going out on a limb? Because of this, you must also see that our program here is sure to have been noticed by the revolutionaries, and to have become a potential target. And you, as our most effective member, must be especially high on their hit list. Before they let us defuse the ticking time bomb of the poor, which they hope to use to shatter the structures of power which exclude them, they will take aim at us. I consider it likely that this woman you have taken a liking to may, in fact, be working for the ERB, and that this trip to the refuse station may be nothing more than a set-up: a trick to lure you away from us, to a lawless and unprotected place where you may be shot down like a dog, or else kidnapped and held for ransom. Even if the guerrillas are not at ‘Pearls to Swine’, it’s filled with gangs and bandits. I won’t let you go."
"We’re here on a mission," I told him, as Dr. Bari listened. "To provide services to the people and show them that they have not been utterly abandoned. Without taking risks, we wouldn’t have made any progress here, at all. Sometimes, you can’t stop. The only way to hold on to what you’ve won is to keep on moving forward. You can’t rest on your laurels, that’s like taking arsenic. Dr. Bari, you must allow me to go with Mina. I’ll have the chance to meet more people, and to do more work."
Reluctantly, after about an hour of philosophical arm-twisting and impassioned reminders of Hippocrates, the doctor agreed. Crossing himself, he said, "May God accompany you every step of the way."
Captain Mendez said: "Don’t do anything stupid. Well, going there to begin with is stupid, so what I mean is don’t do any other stupid things. You’ve got intelligent eyes, I hope they’re not deceptive."
Heart pounding, half believing what they had said, I prepared myself for the trip.
June 2
: As agreed upon, I met Mina and two members of the Quilombolas outside her shack about an hour before dawn on the day of the expedition. An old woman known as "Tia de Todos" had already arrived to watch over Helder and Zenobia, who Mina did not want to risk on the trip. With me, I carried a pack with some medical supplies and rations, a canteen of water, a knife and "all-purpose tool", my pistol in a holster, and my cellphone. I also brought along a good hat, for we were bound to encounter a lot of sun on the way."Good," Mina said, laughing, as she looked me over by the light of a lantern in her hand. "You are ready to go hunting the Coruqueama." I had no idea what that was, but it seemed like one more of the many myths that live alongside them. Mina, herself, brought along two empty sacks made of canvas, a dangerous looking machete, a small
, frighteningly sharp knife, water, some food in a knapsack which she had cooked for us to last the entire journey, and a hat. The young men who came to accompany us had long flowing shirts and baggy pants that seemed to have room for concealed weapons. Besides this possibility, they carried tools for digging."Bye mother, bye mom," the kids said as we prepared to leave. She hugged them in the dark, and said some kind of prayer for them, which wasn’t entirely in Portuguese. "Bye, Mr. Doctor," they told me. Helder, young as he was, said, "If anybody starts any trouble with my mom, don’t hesitate to use that gun at your side." The Quilombolas, whose names were Benedito and Gabriel, laughed.
By dawn, as the first tints of reddish light were oozing into the horizon, we were at the crest of Colina dos Bluns, which hadn’t been easy to climb in the moonlight. When I asked how the hill had got its name, Gabriel made the motions of smoking a joint, and I realized that somehow the English name "blunt" had worked its way down here, and that this hill was a hang-out for drug users, hardly a place to be in the middle of the night. But for some reason we encountered very little traffic on our way up the hill; only one guy who was sitting alone, smiling, and talking to the night. "No, God," he said, "I won’t join them looking for the shit that’s fallen out of rich people’s asses. You’ve given me stars, and Pari-CA." It seemed like some blood was coming out of his nose, but he just wiped it away and said, "You can just put your hands into all this like water - right into the midst of your worst problems - and pull life right out of the pool; nobody can keep it from you."
"Cocaine?" I asked our guides.
Gabriel said, "The jungles of the north have a lot more to offer than that."
On the other side of Colina dos Bluns, we came at last to the reason for the neighborhood’s silence as we left; most of it was already here, in a little valley beside the ascent towards the refuse station, waiting for daylight to begin the journey up. "My god," I said, "it’s like a scene from the Bible. Like the Exodus."
"Except that the whole world’s Egypt," sai